From Fallen London Wiki

"An aspiring corsair seeking to become The Left Hand of Prophecy is advised to become obstinate, at least until their stats are high enough to reliably 100% checks, at which point a Nyx is probably preferable."

As a Corsair who can reliably 100% all checks aside from highway stat checks in the Snares, I can safely say you want to stick with Obstinate regardless, especially if you're grinding Zhip-hunts or Zee-hunts. There's nothing wrong with picking a Zub for fun or roleplaying, but as a Corsair, you WILL be taking on a lot of Troubled Waters even on successes. And thanks to the fact you will very rarely get Zee-menaces from your constant successes, it can lead to dangerous situations of being at 7 TW and having no cards that can lower your TW.